Getting Paid to Care for a Loved One
What Medicaid and the IRS Each Require
Written by Shannon Laymon-Pecoraro, CELA, East Coast Elder Law
A family member can be paid to care for a loved one, but two different sets of rules apply, and each asks a different question. Medicaid asks, "Was this payment really a gift?" The IRS asks: "Is this payment income, and who is the employer?"
Satisfying one agency does not satisfy the other.
We see it constantly. A daughter moves home to care for Mom. Out of gratitude, Mom writes her checks or signs over $50,000 "for everything you've done." Two years later, Mom needs a nursing home, applies for Medicaid, and every one of those payments is treated as a gift. The result is months of ineligibility, right when the family can least afford it. Meanwhile, nobody filed a W-2, and the daughter never reported the money as income.
Done correctly, paying a family caregiver is one of the most effective and fair planning tools available. It keeps a loved one at home, compensates the person doing the work, and legitimately spends down assets. Here is what each agency requires and where the rules part ways.
What Medicaid Requires
Medicaid long-term care is means-tested. To stop applicants from giving assets away to qualify, federal law imposes a 60-month look-back. Any transfer for less than fair market value in the five years before applying triggers a penalty period of ineligibility. Virginia's regulation also presumes that any transfer was made to qualify for Medicaid. The family carries the burden of proving otherwise.
That is the problem with informal caregiver pay. Eligibility workers generally assume that care from a relative is given out of love, not for pay. Without proof of a bargained-for arrangement, payments to a child or grandchild look like gifts. The tool that overcomes this presumption is a personal care agreement (also called a caregiver or services contract). To hold up on review, it should:
Be in writing and signed before the services are paid for. Payment for past care is the classic red flag. Medicaid treats "thank you" money for care already given as a gift.
Pay fair market value. The hourly rate should match local rates for caregiver compensation for comparable services (this often does not match what is paid to an agency, which includes administrative overhead). Overpayment is a transfer of the excess.
Describe the services specifically. Bathing, meals, medication management, transportation, appointments, and bill paying, with an expected schedule.
Pay as services are provided. Weekly or biweekly payments are safest. A large lump-sum prepayment for future care is heavily scrutinized and is often penalized in whole or part.
Be documented. Keep a contemporaneous care log of dates, hours, and tasks. Ideally, a physician's note confirms the need for care.
Not duplicate services. Paying a daughter to provide care that a facility or another program already provides will not be credited.
Getting paid through Medicaid itself. Once a person qualifies for Virginia's Cardinal Care (formerly CCC Plus) home and community-based waiver, family members can often be hired as consumer-directed attendants and paid by the program. Since March 1, 2024, a "legally responsible individual," such as a spouse or the parent of a minor, may be paid for up to 40 hours per week, with only one paid LRI per member. Other relatives, like adult children, are paid under the regular consumer-directed rules.
Why the Medicaid piece matters. When you apply for long-term care Medicaid, the eligibility worker can review five years of bank statements. Every check, transfer, or cash withdrawal to a family caregiver without a compliant agreement can be treated as a gift. The total of those "gifts" is divided by the average monthly cost of private-pay nursing home care, and the result is the number of months Medicaid will not pay. For example, if the divisor were $10,000, $60,000 in undocumented caregiver payments would mean six months of ineligibility.
The timing makes it worse. The penalty does not start when the money was paid. It starts only once your loved one has applied, is in a nursing home, or needs that level of care, and would otherwise qualify. In other words, the penalty hits when the savings are gone, and care costs are highest. The family must then pay privately or get the money back to cure the transfer, often years after the care was given. A properly drafted agreement, signed up front, avoids all of this.
state,
Rules differ by state, and each has its own transfer manuals and caregiver programs, so confirm the details where your loved one lives.
What the IRS Requires
Caregiver pay is taxable income. The IRS is clear that a family caregiver "must still report the compensation as income," even when no employment taxes are owed. Being related does not make the money a gift for tax purposes once there is an agreement to pay for work.
The care recipient is usually an employer. A caregiver working in the recipient's home, at the recipient's direction, is generally a household employee, not an independent contractor. That means the person receiving care (or their agent under a power of attorney) has payroll obligations:
Social Security and Medicare. If cash wages to one household employee reach $3,000 in 2026, the employer withholds 7.65% and pays a matching 7.65%.
Federal unemployment (FUTA). Owed if cash wages exceed $1,000 in any calendar quarter, on the first $7,000 per employee.
Reporting. The employer needs an EIN, issues a W-2, and files Schedule H with their Form 1040. Virginia has its own withholding and unemployment registration.
Family exemptions. Wages paid to your spouse, your child under 21, or your parent (with limited exceptions) are exempt from Social Security, Medicare, and FUTA. The wages are still reportable on a W-2 and still taxable to the caregiver. Note what is not on that list: an adult child caring for a parent, which is the most common arrangement we see. That is fully covered employment.
Medicaid waiver payments can be tax-free. Under IRS Notice 2014-7, payments made through a Medicaid home and community-based waiver may be excluded from the caregiver's income, but only if the caregiver and the care recipient live in the same home, and it is the caregiver's own home. A caregiver who keeps a separate residence does not qualify. Social Security and Medicare may still apply, and the caregiver may elect to count the payments as earned income for the Earned Income Credit. Private payments under a personal care agreement never qualify for this exclusion.
Deductions for the payer are limited. Payments for qualified long-term care can be a deductible medical expense for a chronically ill person. However, the Internal Revenue Code denies that deduction when the caregiver is a relative, unless the relative is a licensed professional for those services.
Where Medicaid and the IRS Differ
They differ in important ways. Medicaid scrutinizes form and timing because it is concerned about hidden gifts. The IRS looks at substance because it is concerned with unreported income. An arrangement can pass one test and fail the other.
Three differences cause the most trouble in practice:
The "gift" that is also income. When Mom pays her daughter $40,000 for care already given, Medicaid calls it a gift and imposes a penalty. The IRS calls it compensation and expects it on the daughter's return. The family can lose on both fronts.
The family exemption that does not exist at Medicaid. Families hear that paying relatives is "exempt" and assume the same is true for Medicaid. It is not. The IRS payroll exemptions have no Medicaid counterpart.
Tax-free waiver pay versus taxable private pay. The same daughter, doing the same work, may owe no income tax on waiver payments if she and Mom share her home. She owes tax on every dollar paid privately under a care agreement.
Getting It Right
Paying a family caregiver honors real work and can protect eligibility, but only when the paperwork matches the reality. A personal care agreement drafted with both Medicaid and the IRS in mind is far less expensive than a penalty period or a tax bill.
If your family is caring for a loved one at home, East Coast Elder Law can help structure the arrangement correctly from the start. We serve families in Virginia, North Carolina, Maryland, and Pennsylvania. Contact our office to schedule a consultation.
This article is for general information only and is not legal or tax advice. Caregiver agreements sit where Medicaid, tax, and family law meet, so who advises you matters.
Shannon Laymon-Pecoraro is a Certified Elder Law Attorney (CELA), certified by the National Elder Law Foundation. The CELA designation requires extensive elder law experience, peer review, and a rigorous written exam. Few attorneys nationwide hold it, and only a few practice it full-time in Virginia. Before you sign a caregiver agreement, consult a CELA about your specific situation.








Comments